Physicians who already own individual disability insurance often ask whether they could get a better policy or lower premium today. Maybe you purchased your coverage during residency, your income and medical specialty have changed, or another disability insurance company now appears to offer similar coverage at a more competitive price.
Replacing an existing physician disability insurance policy, however, is different from purchasing your first policy. Before making a change, you need to understand exactly what you already own and what you could potentially be giving up.
Key Takeaways:
- Should you replace disability insurance just because a new policy is cheaper?
Not necessarily. A lower premium only creates value if you are not sacrificing important contract provisions or benefits to get it. - What should physicians compare before replacing disability insurance?
Compare the actual contracts, including the definition of disability, Own Specialty protection, residual or partial disability benefits, future increase options, benefit periods, and premium guarantees. - Should you cancel your existing disability policy after applying for a new one?
No. Keep the existing policy until the new coverage has completed underwriting, the actual offer has been reviewed and accepted, and the replacement policy is in force. - When does replacing disability insurance make sense?
Replacement may make sense when the new policy provides a meaningful improvement, better protection, more appropriate coverage, premium savings without sacrificing important benefits, or a combination of these advantages.
Does a Cheaper Disability Insurance Policy Mean It Is Better?
Suppose your current individual disability insurance policy costs $400 per month, and another company offers what appears to be similar coverage for $300 per month. Saving $100 monthly, or $1,200 annually, certainly gets your attention.
Before switching policies, however, put the contracts side by side. Does the new policy have the same definition of disability and protect your medical specialty in the same way? How do the residual and partial disability benefits compare? Are the benefit periods the same? What future increase options are available? Are the premiums guaranteed, or could they change?
The question is not simply, “How much am I saving?” You also need to ask, “What am I giving up to save it?”
You may discover you are giving up nothing important. You may also discover that the existing contract contains valuable provisions worth keeping. You will not know until you review the details.
Why Should Physicians Compare Disability Insurance Contracts Instead of Illustrations?
One of the biggest mistakes when considering a disability insurance replacement is comparing only the headlines.
Two policies may both show a $15,000 monthly benefit, a 90-day elimination period, benefits to age 65, and similar premiums. On an illustration, they can look nearly identical.
The actual disability insurance contracts may tell a different story.
Look at how each policy defines Total Disability. How does each contract treat a partial disability or a 20% or 50% loss of income? Can you work in another occupation while receiving total disability benefits? How much additional coverage can you purchase as your physician income increases, and what must you do to qualify? Does your existing policy contain contract features that are no longer available?
Those differences may never matter. If you experience a disability claim, however, they could matter significantly.
What Has Changed Since You Purchased Your Original Disability Insurance?
The policy is not the only thing that may have changed. Your life probably has too.
Your health, physician income, medical specialty, employer disability benefits, family responsibilities, and savings may look very different today than they did when you originally purchased coverage. A disability insurance policy purchased during residency may not be the exact policy you would design as an attending physician years later.
That does not automatically mean you should replace it.
Sometimes the better strategy is to keep the existing policy and add additional coverage. In other situations, modifying the overall disability insurance strategy may make sense. And sometimes, after reviewing everything, the best recommendation is surprisingly simple: What you already own is pretty good. Leave it alone.
When Should You Cancel Your Existing Disability Insurance Policy?
There is one important rule when replacing individual disability insurance: do not cancel your existing policy simply because you submitted a new application.
An application is not a policy. An illustration is not a policy. Even an initial indication from an insurance company is not a final policy offer.
Complete medical and financial underwriting first. Review the actual offer, including any exclusions or limitations. Confirm that the policy issued matches the coverage you intended to purchase. Accept the policy and put the new coverage in force.
Only then should you decide what to do with the existing disability insurance.
The goal is to avoid canceling valuable coverage only to discover that the replacement policy is unavailable on the terms you expected.
When Is Replacing Physician Disability Insurance Worth It?
Replacing disability insurance is not inherently good or bad. It simply needs to have a meaningful reason behind it.
A stronger contract, better protection, coverage that better reflects your current financial situation, or meaningful premium savings without sacrificing important benefits can all justify considering a replacement.
What usually does not justify replacement is a new illustration that simply looks a little better.
From Scott & Amber’s Desk
Before replacing physician disability insurance, understand the policy you already own, compare the actual contracts, evaluate what has changed in your life, and complete underwriting before canceling existing coverage.
The most important question is not whether the new policy is cheaper or newer. It is: Am I getting enough additional value from this disability insurance policy to justify replacing the contract I already have?
Every article in the MD Disability Quotes Knowledge Center is written with one purpose: to help physicians understand insurance contracts before they ever need to rely on them.
About MD Disability Quotes
MD Disability Quotes is a nationwide disability insurance advisory firm specializing in income protection for physicians, dentists, business owners, and other high-income professionals.
Founded by Scott Nelson-Archer and Amber Stitt, the firm brings nearly 40 years of combined experience helping clients evaluate disability insurance contracts, navigate underwriting, and design income protection strategies tailored to specialized careers.
Scott and Amber are the longest-tenured disability insurance experts featured by White Coat Investor. Their education-first approach has helped thousands of physicians better understand disability insurance throughout medical school, residency, fellowship, and practice.
Whether you’re reviewing an existing policy or exploring coverage for the first time, MD Disability Quotes is committed to helping you make informed decisions that protect your ability to earn an income.
If you would like to schedule a disability insurance strategy session, click here.
If you would like to request physician disability insurance quotes, click here.
You can email us: info@mddisabilityquotes.com
Call 713-966-3932 (9 AM-5 PM Central)
Text 281-770-8080 at your convenience.